Tuesday, 15 November 2011

What to look for in a tent

With so many high quality tents on the market these days, where should one start when thinking of buying a tent?  There are a few topics worth considering before choosing your tent.

Design: How and when you plan to use your tent is going to dictate what type of tent you look to buy.  The different types of tent you might consider are:
  • Dome:  Simple design, typically two crossing poles bent into a dome shape, with a flysheet pulled over the top and the inner pegged to the inside.  Moderately stable in poor weather, but will struggle in high winds.  Generally cheaper than other designs, the dome is best suited for those looking for a straight-forward tent for summer camping, perhaps as a family holiday or at festivals.  Dome tents tend to sleep 2-3 people, although larger versions can accommodate 4 or even 5.  The Vango Alpha 250 (right) is a classic entry level dome tent.
  • Geodesic (or semi-geodesic):  The expensive brother of the dome tent, geodesic tents have a series of curved poled ergonomically designed to distribution tension from high winds across the surface of the tent and down into the anchor point.  Poles generally rest on one another, to prevent excess pressure on one point.  These tents are steady as a rock even in dreadful weather, and unlike tunnel tents can tolerate winds from any direction without much trouble.  As a result, geodesic tents tend to be more expensive than other tents.  The Vango Hurricane 200 (right), with its four criss-crossing poles is one of the cheaper geodesics on the market, but don't expect much change from £200.  Only really required by those on expedition or planning for winter camping in hostile climes, but they will also get envious looks at a summer music festival if you've got the money to spend.
  • Tunnel:  The idea behind tunnel designs is that they cut through the wind and as such represent greater stability.  This may be very true on the smaller tents, such as the Force 10 Helium 100 (right, above), which hugs the ground and is steady even in very high winds, but for the larger group tents we suspect that most use the tunnel design because it is the easiest way of accommodating large groups of people.  Group tents with ends that taper down to the ground, such as the Vango Orchy 600 (right, below) are a little more stable than the 'barrel-shaped' alternatives.  A point to note with all tunnel tents, they should be pitched so the 'blunt' end (i.e. where it tapers from the highest point to the ground the most quickly) faces into the wind. 
Weight:  If you are planning on carrying the tent when backpacking or cycle touring, the weight of the tent is going to be very important.  As a good rule of thumb, anything under 1.5 kgs per person should be considered as lightweight. 

Lighter tents are more expensive, as the materials from which they are made are better quality to provide similar conditions at lighter weight, so you should decide whether you really need to go for a super-lightweight tent.  As cool as it might be to brag over titanium tent pegs and poles designed by NASA, you might be able to save lots of money with a slightly heavier tent.  On the other hand, if you are taking part in mountain marathons or keen fairly extreme backpacking then shaving an extra 500g off your total pack weight will pay dividends as you approach the top of your fourth munro of the day.  For example, the Terra Nova Laser Photon 1 (above right) weighs just 720g - lighter than a pint of beer, and just as satisfying at the end of a long day in the hills.

Internal dimensions:  All three internal dimensions, length width and height, are important considerations when choosing your tent. 

Length:  On length, most tents reviewed on this site give between 205cm and 230cm of length.  Remember that the inners of most tents taper down to the bottom edge, so we'd recommend that anyone over 6ft tall probably avoid the 205cm, and anyone over 6ft 4in will find 210cm a little short.  Only the tallest campers should have a problem with 220cm and above.

Width:  One person tents tend to vary from 70cm to 110cm in width.  For two person tents, the width tends to vary from 100cm to 150cm.   For 3+ person tents, a good guide for comfort is 60cm per person.   As a point of reference, a normal sized double bed in the UK is 135cm wide, so a two person tent of close to this width should be more than comfortable enough for two people.

Height:  The internal height of tents varies considerably.  It is only likely to be of importance in group tents, where there is an external area that can be used to relaxing, on which we'd recommend you look for a tent with a max height greater than your own so you can at least stand straight-up.  On smaller tents, less than 80cm of height generally means that it might feel claustrophobic for some campers - but a low profile improves the stability of the tent in high winds.

Hydrostatic Head:  Arguably the most important statistic of a flysheet or groundsheet is the 'hydrostatic head', a rather obscure measure to test what height of water can suspended on the fabric.  A 1000mm hydrostatic head implies that pressure associated with one metre of water can be withstood by the fabric before it begins to leak.  The Ministy of Defence defines materials with a hydrostatic head of 800mm or more as waterproof, whereas most tent manufacturers would consider 1000mm as fully waterproof.

However, the hydrostatic head (often abbreviated to HH) also tells you a lot about the general strength of the material.   High winds can stress the fabric on flysheet, whereas stones and other debris can tear groundsheets, so a high hydrostatic head is beneficial in lots of ways.

Generally speaking, the following guide can be used to the hydrostatic head of flysheets:
  • 1500-2500mm:  Waterproof, but best suited to spring or summer conditions, may show some weakness in high winds or torrential rain and not suited to repeated exposure to poor weather
  • 3000-4000mm:  Suitable for pretty much anything the UK weather can throw at it, but may occasionally suffer in extremely poor weather or wintry conditions
  • 5000mm:  Expedition quality, all-weather fabric
Note that a higher hydrostatic head to the flysheet can adversely affect breathability of the fabric, and as such may worsen condensation issues.

Groundsheets should have a hydrostatic head of at least 6000mm, although 8000-10000mm is more common.  Most modern tents have a 'bathtub' groundsheet design, in that the groundsheet also rises up about 15cm around the base of the tent.  A high hydrostatic head twinned with a bathtub groundsheet should keep you dry even if you pitch your tent on ground which floods (provided that the flood water is not higher than the bathtub lip)

Hopefully this has helped you decide what kind of tent you are looking for - or maybe it has just added to your confusion!  Don't worry, our tent buying guides will help you find the perfect tent in no time.

Tuesday, 1 November 2011

Coleman Pictor X3


Sleeps: 3
Weight: 4.3kg
Dimensions:  Internal 220x180cm, External 200x150cm
Pack size: 51x33x21cm
RRP:  £200

Review:  For a reasonable priced, easy to pitch, lightweight summer tent there are few that can beat the Coleman Pictor X3.  With four big doors that open up the tent completely in nice weather and also a big enough external porch to fit two camping chairs during rain showers, this is pretty much the perfect tent for festivals or as a campsite base.  With a width of 180cm, there are certainly narrower three person tents on the market, but when used for just two this tent feels huge.  All the usual Coleman quirks are here too, colour coded poles, high quality materials, and reflective strips on the guys to help find the tent at night.  On top of all that, it weighs just 4.3kgs which is comfortably in the 'lightweight' end of the three person tent spectrum. If we were being critical, the groundsheet has a hydrostatic head of 5000mm, which is less than most competitors, but unless you're pitching on stony ground or being particularly reckless, this should be more than enough for summer camping.

Best bits:  Big doors, ample external space, lightweight and easy to pitch
Worst bits:  Groundsheet is a bit thin, might not stand up to really bad weather
Alternatives:  The Vango Omega 350 is a bit tougher and a bit heavier

RRP:  £200
Where to get it cheaper:  Click here: £108

Tuesday, 25 October 2011

Terra Nova Laser Competition 2


Sleeps: 2 (at a squeeze)
Weight:  1.25kg
Dimensions:  Internal 220x105cm at the widest point
Pack size:  40x16x16cm
RRP:  £380

Review:  The Terra Nova Laser Competition 2 is the entry-level two-person tent from lightweight pioneers Terra Nova.  At just 1.25kgs, the Laser Competition 2 is one of the lightest two-berths on the market, but it's hard to get two full sized people into this tent easily.  It's even narrower than competitors such as the Force 10 Helium 200 or the cheaper Coleman Rigel X2, and to be honest it is hard to justify this tent over either of those, especially since the Helium 200 is cheaper at most retailers. However, Terra Nova are a small company based in Derbyshire, and those looking to support their local businesses won't have any compliants with any of their excellent quality tents.

Best bits:  Very light, small pack size
Worst bits:  Even narrower than other lightweight two-person tents
Alternatives:  The Force 10 Helium 200 or the cheaper Coleman Rigel X2

RRP:  £380
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £265

Saturday, 15 October 2011

Vango Omega 450

 
Sleeps: 4
Weight: 6kg
Dimensions:  Internal 260x220cm, max height 145cm, external 280x235, max height 155cm
Pack size: 55x21x21cm
RRP:  £235

Review:  A bigger version of the Vango Omega 250 and 350, the Vango Omega 450 is an excellent choice for small groups looking for a hardy, lightweight tent with ample exterior storage space. At just 6kgs, this tent is seriously lightweight when shared between four people, so is ideal for cycle touring (due to the porch space to store the bikes).  260cm of internal width should be more than enough for four people, with a considerably bigger internal footprint than the Vango Icarus 400 or the Vango Orchy 400. As with the smaller models in the Omega range, the design looks very similar to the Vango Beta 450, and so you are really just paying a little extra for the better quality materials.  Read the full review of the smaller tent here for more information on the Omega range.

Best bits:  Lightweight, good external space, high quality materials
Worst bits:   Hard to find any faults with this excellent tent
Alternatives:   If you don't need the extra weatherproofing, then you can save a few pennies with the identical looking Vango Beta 450. For a similar design but with even more weather-proofing, step up to the Vango Equinox 450.

RRP:  £235
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £165

Saturday, 1 October 2011

Coleman Avior X2

 
Sleeps: 2
Weight:  2.45kgs
Dimensions:  Internal 215x125cm
Pack Size:  40x15x15cm
RRP:  £120

Review:  The Coleman Avior X2 is a great quality tent, with nice touches like reflective patches to find your tent in the dark, and two doors to help getting in and out (the side door makes it so much easier than using the end door).   On the downside, the internal space is pretty cosy - it's really a 1.5 person tent rather than a true two-person, and there is very little external space for anything other than a pair of boots, so two big campers with bags will struggle to fit in.   The weather-resistance of this tent is really good for this price level - a 4000mm hydrostatic head for the flysheet, tunnel design and multiple guys means that it holds steady in pretty much any UK conditions. On the inner tent, the roof is a mesh design to allow better air circulation in hot weather.   The tent is a bit heavy for a one-person, but split between two it is very competitive.  However, the best thing about this great little tent is the price - at well under £100 in most stockists this is a very good option in the lightweight and cosy two-person all-weather tent market.

Best bits:  4000HH flysheet, clever design, great price
Worst bits:   Small interior for a two-person
Alternatives:  Shave off a bit of weight for a similar price with the Vango Banshee 200, or get more space by upgrading to the Coleman Avior X3 for a few more pounds.

RRP:  £120
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here - £70

Thursday, 15 September 2011

Vango Hurricane 200 2011

Sleeps: 2
Weight: 4.2kg
Dimensions:  Internal 220x140cm
Pack size: 46x18x18cm
RRP: £300

Read our guide to dome tents here!

Review:  The new Vango Hurricane 200 is a fabulous two-person tent that delivers on so many levels.  A fully geodesic design, 5000mm hydrostatic head flysheet, and Powerlite alloy poles mean that this tent can survive pretty much anything that Mother Nature can throw at it. They don't call it the Hurricane for nothing.  Inside is very roomy - 220cm is enough length for anyone, and the 140cm width is one of the widest light two-person tents on the market.  All these benefits show up in the weight, which at 4.2kg is starting to get into 'heavy' territory for one person to carry, but split between two people it is more than acceptable.  All in all, this is a great tent - but at a RRP of £300 it is expensive - but there is a way around this:  Shop around and you can knock a bit off the price, as we have done below!.

Best bits: Storm-force weather-protection, big interior for a two-person tent
Worst bits:  A bit heavy, trickier to erect than some tents
Alternatives:  Read our comparison of dome tents

RRP:  £300
Where to get it cheaper?:  £204 - Click here

Marmot Grid 2 Person

Sleeps: 2
Weight:  2.7kg
Dimensions: Internal 230x120cm
Pack size:  56x19x19cm
RRP:  £300

Review:  The Marmot Grid is an excellent tent for camping in poor weather and exposed conditions.  The innovative three-pole design is similar to the geodesic design of high altitude expedition tents.  The materials are high quality, with a ripstop nylon flysheet of 5000mm hydrostatic head, lightweight poles and fully taped seams.  Of all the top-end two-person tents this has the best internal dimensions, with a cool 230cm of length suitable for even the tallest campers.  The weight is higher than some competitors in this price-range at 2.7kgs, so might need to be shared between two for backpacking trips, but 1.35kgs each is not going to hurt anyone.  The three pole design means that guys are unnecessary, but it does increase the time taken to erect the tent by a few moments, especially the first time you take it out.  All said, if you can afford it, this is a quality tent with plenty of room for two, which can take all that the elements can throw at it.

Best bits:  Excellent design, roomy inside, high quality tent
Worst bits:  A bit heavier than some backpacking two-person tents
Alternatives:  If you're not so tall, the Force 10 Helium 200 will fight the weather just as well, but is under half the weight.  For total weather resistence step up to this tent's spiritual big-brother, the Terra Nova Ultra Quasar.

RRP: £300
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £264

Thursday, 1 September 2011

Terra Nova Laser Competition 1

Sleeps: 1
Weight:  930g
Dimensions:  220x93cm internal
Pack Size:  40x12x12cm
RRP: £320

Review:  Terra Nova are the premier brand of ultra-lightweight tents, and the Laser Competition 1 is the 'entry-level' one-person tent.  The big positive is the weight, at under 1kg for tent, poles and pegs, this is a seriously light tent.  The tent is primarily aimed at lightweight hiking and mountain marathons, but is too expensive for any other use.  At just 220cm in length, this tent can feel a little cramped for taller campers.  However, the big problem that this tent faces is that it falls between two stools - it is more expensive that some of the newer, more roomy, double-skinned tents that weigh around 1kg, but it is heavier than the best ultra-lightweight tents which can be had for just a few more pounds.  However, if you are not very tall and want a very good quality tent for lightweight hiking or competition, then the Laser Competition 1 will be a good choice if you can get it at the right price - we've scoured the net to knock nearly £100 off the RRP, at which point the tent becomes competitive.

Best bits: Lightweight, excellent quality as you'd expect from the Terra Nova brand
Worst bits: Costs a little more than comparable newer tents
Alternatives:  Add 220g and get the Force 10 Helium 100 which is also longer, or add a few quid and get the Terra Nova Laser Photon 1

RRP:  £320
Where to get it cheaper?: Click here: £224

Monday, 22 August 2011

Coleman Novae X2

Sleeps: 2
Weight: 1.9kgs
Dimensions:  Internal 220x130cm (at its widest)
Pack size:  53x16x16cm
RRP:  £230

Review:  The Coleman Novae X2 is a lightweight two man tent with an interesting design that sees the flysheet hang from an external structure of poles, and then the inner hangs from the flysheet.  At 1.9kgs, this tent is lighter than most of its competitors and might suit two people on a backpacking trip.  However, the internal space in this tent is cosy - at its narrowest the tent is just 80cm - and the flysheet is only 2000mm HH, which means it is somewhat weaker than some of its competitors.  For us, we think there are potentially better options on the market - the Vango Banshee 200 is only 100grams heavier, about half the price and made of better materials than the Novae X2.   Plus, if you really want lightweight, the Force 10 Helium 200 is just 1.3kgs for about the same price - although you do lose a few more centimetres of width.

Best bits:  Lightweight, interesting design
Worst bits:  There are lighter and better options on the market for around the same price

RRP:  £230
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £146

Saturday, 20 August 2011

Vango Atlas 200

Sleeps: 2
Weight: 3.5kgs
Dimensions: Internal 210x140cm
Pack Size: 40x17x16cm
RRP: £60
Review:  The Vango Atlas 200 is a great take on the traditional dome tent with a door on either side of the tent, which allows either camper to leave the tent without disturbing the other.  Apart from that, everything else here is as you'd expect from a budget dome tent.  The weight is tolerable for two people to carry and the internal space is good - 140cm of width is bigger than you'd get in a lot of the more expensive two person tents.  The materials are as good as you'd expect from any Vango entry-level tent, with a 3000mm HH flysheet and the same Powerflex poles as they use on lots of tents in the range.  Honestly, we love this tent, and think it's a great budget option for two people who want a good quality tent and don't mind carrying a few extra grams.

Best bits:  Cheap, clever two-door design, more spacious inside than some two person tents
Worst bits:  Won't stand up to very poor weather, slightly heavier than some dome tents

RRP:  £60
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £49.99

Sunday, 14 August 2011

Vango Alpha 250


Sleeps: 2
Weight:  3.3kg
Dimensions:  Internal 205x150cm
Pack size:  57x15x15cm
RRP:  £55

Review:  The Vango Alpha 250 is a much better option than the Vango Alpha 200 for a similar price, with decent width but still only 205cm of length so taller campers might find it a bit short.  However, as an entry level dome tent this fits the one really fits the bill.  It shouldn't be expected to stand up to winter conditions, but for summer camping or as a festival tent the Vango Alpha 250 is a great option.

Best bits:  Cheap and roomy, good quality dome tent
Worst bits:  Entry level quality occassionally shows
Alternatives:  The Sigma range is a step up in terms of quality, but comes at increased price

RRP: £55
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £40

Vango Alpha 200


Sleeps:  2 (only just)
Weight: 2.75kg
Dimensions:  Internal 205x120cm
Pack size:  50x16x16cm
RRP:  £50

Review:  The Vango Alpha 200 is the entry level dome tent from Vango, although its hard to see why you'd choose this tent over one of the larger tents in the same range.  The internal dimensions in the 200 are tiny, stepping up to the Vango Alpha 250 gives you much more room for just a few more pounds.  The materials are okay, with a 3000mm HH flysheet, which should stand up to the odd downpour but you might want to upgrade to a better quality tent for anything other than summer camping. 

Best bits:  Cheap and sturdy dome tent
Worst bits:  Tiny inside
Alternatives:  Upgrade to the Alpha 250 or the Alpha 300 for about the same price and get a lot more room

RRP:  £50
Where to get it cheaper:  Click here: £37

Coleman Pictor X2

Sleeps: 2
Weight:  3.35kg
Dimensions:  Internal 220x120cm, External 135x120cm
Pack size:  47x30x19cm
RRP:  £170

Review:  The Coleman Pictor X2 is a good quality two person tunnel tent, which should suit campers looking for relatively lightweight options that also have external space to keep bags or other luggage.  A similar design to the Vango Omega 250, but slightly lighter and slighter smaller, the Pictor X2 is a better choice for those who don't need the expedition-standard materials found on the Omega and don't mind a fairly cosy internal space. Easy to pitch, and comes with all the usual Coleman touches like colour-coded poles and reflective strips to help find the tent in the dark, this is a good tent for a reasonable price.  If the narrowness of the internal space is a problem, one could always upgrade to the Coleman Pictor X3, which adds a huge 60cms to the internal width for an extra £20 or so.

Best bits:  Rare to find a two person tent with good external space for less than 3.5kgs
Worst bits:  Narrow inside
Alternatives:  If the narrowness really is a problem, upgrade to the Coleman Pictor X3.  If you're planning on using this is bad weather, consider the Vango Omega 250.

RRP:  £170
Where to get it cheaper:  £89 here

Sunday, 7 August 2011

Vango Omega 350

 
Sleeps: 3
Weight:  5.15kg
Dimensions: Internal 215x200cm, max height 125cm, external 220x200cm, max height 135cm
Pack size:  48x19x19cm
RRP: £185

Review:  The Vango Omega 350 is a bigger version of the Vango Omega 250 so read the full review here for more detail.  The step up from the 250 to the 350 sees 60cms added to the internal width, which makes this tent feel generous for three people (whereas the Omega 250, at 140cm wide, is average for two people).  Otherwise, more of the same from this excellent Vango range.

Best bits:  Lightweight, good external space, high quality materials
Worst bits:   Hard to find any faults with this excellent tent
Alternatives:   If you don't need the extra weatherproofing, then you can save a few pennies with the identical looking Vango Beta 350.  For a similar design but with even more weather-proofing, step up to the Vango Equinox 350.
RRP:  £185
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £125

Vango Omega 250

Sleeps: 2
Weight:  4.25kg
Dimensions:  215x140cm, external space of 200x160, max height 120cm
Pack size:  47x18x18cm
RRP:  £180

Review: The Vango Omega 250 is the smallest tent in the Omega range.  More hardy that the similar shaped Vango Beta 250, the Omega is designed for expedition activies that demand additional external space - such as mountain biking (there is space to keep a bike or two safe in the porch) - and is recommended kit for the Duke of Edinburgh Award Scheme in the UK.  The flysheet is stronger than the Beta, with a 5000mm hydrostatic head vs 3000mm. The Omega also shaves 650g of weight off the Beta model.  The internal space in the Omega is tolerable - it can feel a little cramped if you keep your bags in the inner, but there are plenty of smaller ones on the market.    The external porch has its own groundsheet, although if you are storing bikes in this section it can get dirty quite quickly.  As with all new expedition Vango tents, the poles eyelets come with tension straps to improve stability, and the tunnel design and high quality materials mean that the tent can withstand most weather conditions in the UK.  For further stability, you'd have to look to a semi-geodesic model such as the Vango Halo or Vango Hurricane, but you'd have to sacrifice the external space.  For a good quality tent with plenty of storage, it's hard to beat the Omega range.

Best bits:  Lightweight, good external space, high quality materials
Worst bits:   Hard to find any faults with this excellent tent
Alternatives:   If you don't need the extra weatherproofing, then you can save a few pennies with the identical looking Vango Beta 250.  For a similar design but with even more weather-proofing, step up to the Vango Equinox 250.

RRP:  £180
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £159

Saturday, 6 August 2011

Vango Halo 200

 
Sleeps: 2
Weight:  3.5kg
Dimensions:  Internal 210x140cms
Pack size:  40x17x17cm
RRP:  £150

Review:  The Vango Halo 200 is a high quality and fairly spacious two person tent at a reasonable price.  The semi-geodesic/dome design paired with a 5000HH flysheet means good weather resistance, whereas the symmetric double-door system and capacious external space (for an expedition tent) means easy access to the tent and to your belongings.  As with most of the new expedition tents from Vango, the Halo 200 come with tension straps on the eyelets for the poles and a clever V-shaped guy rope system on each side to equalise the tension across the poles.  The groundsheet is a sturdy, bathtub design which should stand up well to pretty much anything, and you shouldn't need a footprint for this tent - although it does help it to keep clean if nothing else.  The only downside to this tent is the weight, which still isn't too heavy between two, but for one person there are lighter alternatives - albeit at a higher cost.  A fabulous tent.

Best bits:  High quality, clever design, reasonable price
Worst bits:   A little heavier than some expedition alternatives.
Alternatives: The Vango Banshee 200 is lighter, but tighter inside.

RRP:  £150
Where to get it cheaper?:  Click here: £108